What is your stuff really worth? An honest guide to selling, donating and passing things on
Updated October 15, 2026. General information, not financial, tax or legal advice.
This is the part nobody wants to say out loud: most of what's in a long-time home won't sell for much. It isn't a judgment on your taste. Buyers' tastes changed, and a lot of people are downsizing at the same time, so the market is full of the same things. Knowing that up front saves months of waiting for offers that don't come.
What's often hard to sell
- Formal dining sets and "brown furniture": big, dark, traditional pieces. Beautifully made, but there are a lot of them for sale.
- China, crystal and silver plate. Full sets often sell for a fraction of what they cost.
- Upright pianos. Many are given away free, because moving them costs more than they sell for.
- Most collectibles: figurines, plates, commemorative coins at face value, and the things that were sold as future heirlooms.
- Large entertainment centers, encyclopedias and old electronics. Recycle the electronics properly.
What often does better than people expect
- Mid-century modern furniture, the clean-lined pieces from roughly the 1950s through the 1970s.
- Sterling silver and gold. Even when the style isn't popular, the metal is worth something.
- Quality tools, garden equipment and workshop gear.
- Some art, vintage designer items, watches and vinyl records. Worth a professional look before you price them.
- Newer furniture in good shape, especially smaller pieces that fit apartments.
Who to call, and for what
- An appraiser for anything you think may be valuable. Look for credentials from the American Society of Appraisers, the Appraisers Association of America or the International Society of Appraisers. Pay a flat or hourly fee, not a share of the value, and don't sell to the person who appraised it.
- An auction house for real valuables: fine art, jewelry, rare collectibles.
- An estate sale company to price and sell most of a home's contents at once. Ask what share they keep, whether there's a minimum, what happens to what doesn't sell, and whether they're insured.
- A consignment shop for good furniture and decor. They sell it for you and keep a share.
- Online marketplaces for single items you're willing to show to strangers. Meet in a public place or have someone with you.
- Charities for what's left that's still useful. Habitat for Humanity ReStores take furniture and building materials, and many pick up. Ask for a receipt if you itemize your taxes.
- A junk removal company for the true leftovers. Some donate what they can.
The order that saves the most time
- Family first. Let the people close to you claim what they want, by a set date. See how to have that talk.
- Find the valuables. Get anything that might be worth real money looked at.
- Sell through the right channel for each thing.
- Donate what's useful.
- Clear out the rest in one day.
Before anything leaves the house
Check pockets, drawers, books and boxes. Cash, jewelry, savings bonds, deeds, titles and wills turn up in the strangest places. Shred old papers with account numbers on them. And keep the stories: a photo of the piece and a few lines about where it came from can mean more to someone than the piece itself.
Common questions
Is it better to have an estate sale or sell things myself?
An estate sale is faster and usually better when you have a whole house to clear. Selling things yourself can bring more per item but takes a lot of time. Many people do both: sell a few valuable pieces themselves, then let an estate sale handle the rest.
Why won't anyone buy my china?
A lot of people are selling full sets at the same time, and fewer people want them. Offer it to family first, sell single pieces to replacement services if they're a popular pattern, or donate it.
How do I know if something is valuable?
Get it looked at by a credentialed appraiser who charges a flat or hourly fee. Don't rely on online listings: asking prices aren't selling prices.
Sort it room by room
Will It Fit? tells you which furniture fits your next home, and keeps your keep, sell, give and family lists in one place.
Try Will It Fit?Not sure where to start? Take the stay-or-go check. A few taps, results right away.